Auto advice

Used car buying guide

A complete 10-step playbook for finding, evaluating, and purchasing a used vehicle — with expert tips at every stage of the process.

10

Step process

40+

Expert tips

10

Top picks under $6K

Used vehicles at a dealership lot

On this page

Step 1 of 10

How Much Car Can You Afford?

A general guideline is that your monthly car payment should not be more than 20 percent of your take-home pay. However, people shop for cars with their hearts as well as their heads, and that can be a little dangerous.

Keep monthly payment under 20% of take-home pay
Factor in insurance, fuel, and maintenance costs
Get pre-approved financing before you shop
Budget an emergency repair fund on top of purchase price

Budget Rule

The 20% rule is a ceiling, not a target. The lower your payment relative to income, the more financial freedom you keep.

Step 2 of 10

Build a Target List of Used Cars

To save money, consider buying a second-tier car, from the less popular - but still reliable - manufacturers. Well-known vehicles like the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry can cost thousands more than a comparable Chevrolet Malibu or Nissan Altima, even though these are good cars. With this in mind, build a target list of three different cars that meet your needs and fall in your budget.

Research reliability ratings from Consumer Reports and J.D. Power
Compare cost of ownership, not just sticker price
Consider 2nd-tier brands for equivalent quality at lower cost
Aim for 3 target vehicles, not just one, for negotiating flexibility

Smart Pick

Vehicles like the Nissan Altima and Chevrolet Malibu often offer 90% of the Honda/Toyota experience at 70% of the price.

Step 3 of 10

Check Prices and Reviews

To see if the cars you are looking at fit into your budget, check True Market Value (TMV) pricing. Edmunds.com's TMV shows you what other people are paying for that car in your area. Also use True Cost to Own (TCO) to see what other ownership expenses you are likely to incur, including fuel economy, insurance, and maintenance.

Use Edmunds TMV to see real-world pricing in your zip code
True Cost to Own (TCO) reveals total 5-year ownership cost
Cross-reference multiple review sources - never rely on one
Check owner forums for common problems with specific model years

Pro Resource

Edmunds, Kelley Blue Book, and CarGurus each use different data models. Check all three and average the values.

Step 4 of 10

Locate Used Cars for Sale in Your Area

You can filter the search by many factors including distance, mileage, price and features to find exactly the car you want. Use sites like AutoTrader.com, eBay Motors, CarGurus.com, and Craigslist. There are also many places to shop in person, such as independent used car lots, the used car section of a new car dealership, and used car superstores.

Cast a wide net - AutoTrader, CarGurus, Facebook Marketplace, eBay Motors
Expand your search radius by 50-100 miles for rare models
Private party sales often beat dealer prices by $1,000-$3,000
Used car superstores like CarMax offer certified vehicles with no-haggle pricing

Local Tip

Maryland has some of the most active private-party markets. Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace can yield incredible deals within 30 miles.

Step 5 of 10

Check the Vehicle History Report

Before you contact a used-car seller, you should get a vehicle history report for the car you're interested in buying. This is an essential first step: If the report is negative, you should not go any further with this car. AutoCheck and Carfax are the two best-known sources. These reports can reveal if the vehicle has a salvage title, odometer rollback, or undisclosed accident history.

Never skip the vehicle history report - treat it as non-negotiable
Carfax and AutoCheck both reveal salvage titles and accident history
Check for odometer rollback flags - a major red flag for fraud
A clean report doesn't guarantee no problems, but it narrows your risk

Critical Step

A salvage title means the vehicle was declared a total loss by an insurance company. Walk away - financing it is nearly impossible and resale value plummets.

Step 6 of 10

Contact the Seller

Once you find a good prospective car, call the seller before you go to see the vehicle. Establish a relationship and verify the information in the ad. Sometimes the seller will mention something that wasn't in the ad that might change your decision. Set up a test-drive appointment during daytime so you can see the car in natural lighting.

Call - don't just text. A phone call reveals hesitation and inconsistencies
Ask how long they've owned it and why they're selling
Request the service records before committing to a visit
Schedule the test-drive during daylight - paint defects hide at night

Timing Matters

Morning appointments give you the best light for exterior inspection. Avoid looking at cars under artificial lot lighting - it masks paint repairs and rust.

Step 7 of 10

Test-Drive the Car

Test-driving a used car not only tells you if this is the right car for you, but also if this particular car is in good condition. Simulate your normal driving patterns - if you do a lot of highway driving, take it up to at least 65 mph. After the drive, ask to see service records. Avoid cars that have had major repairs such as transmission rebuilds, valve jobs, or engine overhauls.

Highway test drive
Drive it on highway AND in stop-and-go traffic - both matter
Test all electronics: AC, heat, windows, radio, backup camera
Listen for unusual noises over bumps, during acceleration, and braking
Check brake feel - soft or pulsing pedal signals worn rotors

Drive Right

Bring a trusted friend with a good eye for cars. A second set of ears and eyes catches things you'll miss when you're excited about a purchase.

Step 8 of 10

Have the Car Inspected

If you like the way the car drives, have it inspected by a trusted mechanic before you negotiate to buy it. A pre-purchase inspection can save you thousands of dollars. A private party will usually allow this without resistance. If it is a CPO (Certified Pre-Owned) car, there is less need - but even then, a second opinion doesn't hurt.

Mechanic inspecting a vehicle
Budget $100-$200 for a pre-purchase inspection - always worth it
Use your own mechanic, not one recommended by the seller
Ask for a written report listing everything found
Use inspection findings as negotiating leverage on price

Money Saver

A $150 inspection that catches a $2,000 transmission issue is the best investment you'll make. Never waive this step.

Step 9 of 10

Negotiate Your Best Deal

Negotiating with a private-party seller can be quick and relaxed. Negotiating at a dealership takes longer and can be stressful. The key is knowing your walk-away number before you start - and meaning it.

Open low but in the ballpark - not insultingly low
Anchor to TMV data and inspection findings, not emotion
Your walk-away is your strongest negotiating tool - use it
Don't be distracted by add-ons: extended warranties, protection plans, rust coatings

Key Principle

Decide your maximum number before you walk in. Never negotiate past it. Dealers are trained to keep you in the room until you say yes - walking out resets the dynamic.

Step 10 of 10

Close the Deal

At a dealership, you'll close in the Finance & Insurance (F&I) office. If buying from a private party, ensure payment is final and the seller properly transfers title and registration. Have insurance in place before you drive away. Review every line of the sales contract - it should list vehicle cost, doc fee, smog certificate, sales tax, and license fees. When buying private party, pay via cash or cashier's check and get the signed title before any money changes hands.

Signing vehicle paperwork
Secure insurance BEFORE you drive the car off the lot
Read the full contract - every line, every fee
For private sales: cashier's check only, title signed before payment
In Maryland, you have 60 days to title and register your new vehicle

Maryland Note

After closing the deal, MVA Services with Speed can handle your title transfer and registration same-day - no DMV line required.

Editor's list

Top 10 used cars under $6,000

These vehicles offer the best combination of reliability, value, and cost of ownership in the sub-$6K market.

🥇

2015 Chevrolet Spark 1LT

Under $6,000

🥈

2011 Buick Enclave CXL-2

Under $6,000

🥉

2003 Nissan Frontier

Under $6,000

#4

2010 Acura MDX

Under $6,000

#5

2002 Mercedes-Benz S-Class S500

Under $6,000

#6

2016 Nissan Leaf S

Under $6,000

#7

2012 Cadillac CTS

Under $6,000

#8

2014 Subaru Outback 2.5i

Under $6,000

#9

2013 Kia Optima SX

Under $6,000

#10

2014 Honda Civic LX

Under $6,000

Just bought a used car? We handle the paperwork.

Skip the MVA line entirely. MVA Services with Speed handles your title transfer, tag issuance, and registration — same day, no stress.

Same-day processing100% MVA compliantNo hidden fees